Deadly Brazilian Butt Lifts

In my previous blog Brazilian Butt Lift - Buttock Augmentation Implants and Injections I discussed the history of buttock augmentation, the surgery and illegal buttock injections by untrained individuals leading to loss of life. According to statistics from the American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ASAPS) plastic surgeons, dermatologists, and facial plastic surgeons performed 18,487 of these procedures in the US in 2015 compared to 7,382 in 2011, a 150% increase over 4 years. The total from 2011 through 2015 is estimated at over 65,000. If other surgeons are included the 2015 total could have been as high as 23,000 and the 2011 through 2015 numbers as high as 100,000. In 2015 a buttock procedure (fat grafting, buttock implant or buttock lift) was performed in the US every 30 minutes of every day. Now as the procedure becomes increasingly popular with surgeons it has become obvious that this is the mostly deadly procedure performed by plastic and cosmetic surgeons.

To investigate this ASAPS created a task force, which surveyed, queried and interviewed medical malpractice carriers, state medical boards, individual plastic surgeons world wide, American medical examiners and U.S. autopsy reports in July 2016. 25 deaths associated with the procedure were confirmed by individual surgeons and medical examiners over the previous 5 years. 4 deaths were reported between 2014 and 2015 by the American office operating room accreditation entity AAAASF. That translates to 1 death every 2 to 3 months from this procedure. The very first case report of death following buttock fat injection due to fat travelling to the lungs (pulmonary fat embolization-PFE) was published in the pathology literature in 2015. I am also aware of deaths from the procedure due to puncture of large arteries or bowel with the metal tubes used to harvest or inject the fat. The ASAPS task force consisted of 11 surgeons, pathologists, and statisticians who limited their study to the risks of both fatal and nonfatal fat embolization. Most non-fatal fat embolization cases require a stay in the intensive care unit on a ventilator breathing machine and may result in permanent lung impairment.

The queried surgeons accounted for a career total of 198,857 cases. In this group there were 32 fatal and 103 non-fatal fat embolization cases. Over the previous 12 months (July 2015 to July 2016) this group had performed 17,519 cases resulting in 5 fatal and 12 nonfatal pulmonary fat embolization cases. That is almost 1 death every 2 months and 1 case requiring hospitalization in the intensive care unit per month. Surgeon experience i.e. number of cases performed was not statistically related to the number of pulmonary fat embolization cases. About half of the surgeons reported having performed 50 or fewer cases. The technique used/described by the surgeon though was statistically associated with increased risk of having either complication.

Transverse View of the Right Side of the Body at Hip Level

Factors Statistically Increasing the Risk of Pulmonary Fat Embolization-PFE

Factor	Increased Risk of Fatal PFE	Increased Risk of non-Fatal PFE
Deep Muscle Fat Injection	4x	6x
Mid-Superficial Muscle Fat Injection	0.2x	0.2x
Cannula Perpendicular to Skin	3.9x	3.7x
Cannula Parallel to Skin	0.6x	0.4x
Multiple Holes in Cannula	2.5x	2.4x

Autopsies on only 2 patients out of 22 Brazilian Butt Lift deaths in Mexico and Columbia showed disruption of the blood vessels deep to the gluteus maximus muscle, which could explain how fat traveled via those veins from the buttocks to the lungs.

Clearly deep buttock fat injections are problematic with 4 to 6 fold increases in fat emboli complications but fatal PFE have been reported with superficial injection as well. A 2016 review of the medical literature yielded 17 case studies and 2 retrospective reviews totaling over 4,000 patients where 46.7% of the articles recommended fat injection into the fat and muscle layers of the buttock, 26.7% recommended injection only into the muscle and 26.7% recommended injection only superficial to the muscle. This leaves us with more questions than answers. Do the surgeons really know the level or depth of their fat injections? Do the size of fat particles injected, total amount of fat injected, patient position on the operating table, syringe vs. ratchet gun injection and/or the entry site of the injection cannula make a difference? Does a small percentage of the population have an anatomical anomaly that predisposes them to this? Does injecting while the cannula is moving outward rather than inward make a difference?

This is a patient of mine in whom I performed fat grafting to the buttocks at the same time as a body lift. You can estimate the amount of skin removed by the size of the dog's head.

46 year old, 5'8", 167 pound patient 31 days after liposuction, tummytuck revision, rib removal, and fat transfer to the buttocks augmentation i.e. Brazilian butt lift, Latin butt.

January 31, 2018 Addendum:
A Multi-Society Gluteal Fat Grafting Task Force consisting of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, the American Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons, the International Society of Aesthetic Plastc Surgeons, the International Society of Plastic Reconstructive and Esthetic Surgeons and the International Federation for Adipose Therapeutics and Science has issued a safety advisory based on autopsy findings that all deceased Brazilian Butt Lift patients have:

1. fat in the gluteal muscles; 
2. fat beneath the muscles; 
3. damage to the superior or inferior gluteal vein; 
4. massive fat emboli in the heart and/or lungs. 

The task force, therefore, made these suggestions to surgeons:

1. Stay as far away from the gluteal veins and sciatic nerve as possible. Fat should only be grafted into the superficial planes, with the subcutaneous space considered safest. If the aesthetic goal requires more fat than can be placed in the subcutaneous layer the surgeon should consider staging the procedure rather than injecting deep.
2. Concentrate on the position of the cannula tip throughout every stroke to assure there is no unintended deeper pass, particularly in the medial half of the buttock overlying the critical structures.
3. Use access incisions that best allow a superficial trajectory for each part of the buttock; avoid deep angulation of the cannula; and palpate externally with the non-dominant hand to assure the cannula tip remains superficial.
4. Use instrumentation that offers control of the cannula; avoid bendable cannulas and mobile luer connections. Vibrating injection cannulas may provide additional tactile feedback.
5. Injection should only be done while the cannula is in motion in order to avoid high pressure bolus injections.
6. The risk of death should be discussed with every prospective BBL patient.

As a result grafting over 2 or more surgical sessions may become more common.

October 4, 2018 Addendum:
The British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons told its members to stop performing Brazilian butt lifts because it has the highest death rate of all cosmetic surgery procedures -- estimated to be as high as 1 in 3,000 operations. Also because of associated complications including bacterial infections, such as MRSA or necrosis (tissue death). There has been a six fold jump since 2013 in patients visiting one British hospital due to botched surgeries done abroad. Five out of six "major" complications cases were due to Brazilian butt lifts and patients stayed on average 20 days in the hospital costing the health care service £32,500 pounds, about $42,294 each. Most went to Turkey, followed by Belgium, France, Cyprus, Tunisia and Colombia.  A quarter of patients travelled primarily for lower-cost procedures.

Call today for a consultation!
310-246-0537
Free Fat Grafting
Dr. Aaron Stone - Plastic Surgeon Los Angeles
Dr. Stone's Twitter
Dr. Stone's Facebook